ACTER26: CTE RESEARCH AND PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT CONFERENCE
PROGRAM FOR WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 11TH
Days:
previous day
all days

View: session overviewtalk overview

08:00-10:00 Session 10: Reviewer Training

Interested in learning to write expert and constructive peer reviews? Join Dr. Threeton in this session to discover the elements of a helpful and learn how to get involved with reviewing the JCTE and CTER. Graduate students and early career professionals are encouraged to join.

Chair:
Mark Threeton (Pennsylvania State University, United States)
08:15-10:00 The Wittliff Collections

The Wittliff Collections collect, preserve, and present the cultural heritage of Texas, the Southwest & Mexico through works of the region’s storytellers—writers, photographers, musicians, filmmakers, and other artists—to educate, engage and inspire.

A group, led by TXST graduate students, will walk over together to explore the current exhibits.

learn more: thewittliffcollections.txst.edu

10:15-11:15 Session 11A: Research Papers #5
Chair:
Catalina Vasquez (University of Texas, United States)
Discussant:
Michelle Bartlett (Old Dominion University, United States)
Location: 314, LBJ Center
10:15
Dr. Ryan Lundell (Santa Clara University, United States)
Dr. Jonathan Montoya (Saint Mary's College, United States)
Dr. Pedro Nava (Santa Clara University, United States)
Beyond Technical Skills: Community-Engaged Critical CTE in a Dual-Enrollment Construction Technology Course
PRESENTER: Dr. Ryan Lundell

ABSTRACT. Career and Technical Education (CTE) emphasizes authentic learning experiences that prepare students for postsecondary education and the workforce; however, less is known about how students experience instructional models that integrate technical learning with community engagement. This qualitative case study examined the Community-Engaged Critical CTE instructional model, an extension of the Critical CTE Framework, in a dual-enrollment construction technology course involving 28 students. Data included interviews, focus groups, surveys, reflections, classroom observations, and student artifacts collected over one semester. Findings indicate that authentic technical projects, student autonomy, collaboration, community inquiry, and authentic public audiences fostered meaningful learning, ownership, civic understanding, and confidence. These findings suggest that community-engaged instructional models can broaden the educational purpose of technical education while strengthening workforce preparation.

10:30
Cara DeLoach (Tennessee Board of Regents (TBR), United States)
Adult Learners and the College Experience: Qualitative Insights from the Next Steps Coaching Model at Tennessee Community Colleges

ABSTRACT. In 2023, two Tennessee community colleges launched the Next Steps Coaching Project, a high-touch, relational advising program for adult learners. To ensure placement in high-demand, high-wage employment opportunities, the holistic coaching model was designed to provide adult learners with guided career exploration connected with their course and college experiences. Quantitative results from the program’s randomized control trial demonstrated modest, positive impacts of coaching on adult learners’ success. To learn more about adult learners’ experiences working with Next Steps coaches, this qualitative study collected more than 3,000 minutes of qualitative data from interviews, observations, and focus groups with adult learners. Results provide important insights for how community colleges can better engage adult learners in advising and career exploration through holistic coaching.

10:45
Dylan Carpenter (Texas State University, United States)
Ryan Anderson (Texas State University, United States)
Does a Relationship Exist Between School-Based Agricultural Education Teachers Knowledge to Teach Electricity and Their Ability to Perform Electrical Skills
PRESENTER: Dylan Carpenter

ABSTRACT. This study sought to determine if a relationship existed between their knowledge to teach electricity and their ability to perform the electrical skills. Each skill was correlated within the corresponding skill area rather than across skill areas. For example, the knowledge to teach electrical safety in SBAE was correlated to the perceived ability to perform electrical safety.

10:15-11:15 Session 11B: Research Papers #6
Chair:
Jason Segrest (The Ohio State University, United States)
Discussant:
Catherine Arley-Forsten (foundry10, United States)
Location: 315, LBJ Center
10:15
Anthony Gray (Dunwoody College of Technology, United States)
Brandon Hensley (Old Dominion University, United States)
James Bartlett (Old Dominion University, United States)
From Recruitment Communications to Q Statements: A Framework for Developing an Employer-Recruitment Concourse
PRESENTER: James Bartlett

ABSTRACT. Online job advertisements are a large, accessible body of employer communication, yet Q methodology offers little guidance on using them as concourse material. This methodological paper proposes a six-phase framework for transforming skilled-trades job advertisements into an employer-recruitment concourse and a pilot-ready Q sample: recruitment communication collection, statement extraction, concourse development, thematic categorization, Q statement refinement and sample construction, and expert review and pilot testing, supported by an audit trail. The framework treats job advertisements as institutionally mediated discourse rather than direct statements of employer belief. A worked illustration with North Carolina electrician postings shows how advertisement text becomes a sortable Q statement. The framework is designed to promote transparency and replicability in concourse development.

10:30
James Bartlett (Old Dominion University, United States)
Michelle Bartlett (Old Dominion University, United States)
A Question-Driven Framework for Knowledge Development in Career and Technical Education
PRESENTER: James Bartlett

ABSTRACT. Career and technical education (CTE) research addresses diverse scientific purposes, yet little attention has been given to how research questions shape knowledge generation and evidence selection. This study developed a Question–Evidence Alignment Framework by classifying 92 research questions from 51 empirical and evidence-synthesis articles published in Career and Technical Education Research (2021–2026). Using qualitative content analysis, nine categories of research questions were identified based on scientific purpose. Building on this taxonomy, the proposed framework conceptualizes disciplinary knowledge development as a sequential process in which research questions define scientific purpose, scientific purpose determines knowledge generation, and knowledge requirements guide evidence, methodology, and analysis. The framework provides a foundation for evaluating, synthesizing, and advancing the cumulative knowledge base of CTE research.

10:45
Paula Gray (Old Dominion University, United States)
Anthony Gray (Dunwoody College of Technology, United States)
Professional Identity Development in Postsecondary Career and Technical Education: The Professional Identity in Practice Framework
PRESENTER: Paula Gray

ABSTRACT. Professional identity development (PID) has been linked to workforce readiness, persistence, and successful transitions into employment, yet limited theory explains how identity develops when learners participate in work and education simultaneously. This conceptual paper proposes the Professional Identity in Practice Framework, a participation-based explanation of PID among postsecondary career and technical education (CTE) students. Grounded in Communities of Practice and Legitimate Peripheral Participation, and developed through an integrative literature review, the Framework identifies five interrelated mechanisms: authentic participation, reflection, mentorship, professional socialization, and agency. It offers five propositions and indicators across participation, recognition, and self-identification to guide future empirical research. The Framework positions postsecondary CTE as a distinct context in which learners hold student and practitioner roles concurrently.

10:15-11:15 Session 11C: Research Papers #7
Chair:
Matthew Bornak (Pennsylvania State University, United States)
Discussant:
Sam Rodriguez (Fresno State University, United States)
Location: 316, LBJ Center
10:15
Jewlyann Cruz (Texas State University, United States)
Ryan Anderson (Texas State University, United States)
Determining the impact of a Professional Development Workshop on SBAE Teachers' Knowledge and Ability to Teach Electricity
PRESENTER: Jewlyann Cruz

ABSTRACT. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the relationship between SBAE teachers’ perceived knowledge of electricity and their perceived ability to teach electricity following participation in an electricity-focused professional development workshop.The findings of this study suggest that positive relationships exist between SBAE teachers’ perceived knowledge of electricity and their perceived ability to teach electricity-related skills across the four constructs examined: electrical safety and tools, switches and receptacles, making electrical connections, and electrical testing. The findings also suggest the workshop had an impact on knowledge and ability to teach electrical testing.

10:30
Haley Matney (Texas State University, United States)
Ryan Anderson (Texas State University, United States)
Powering Instruction: The Relationship Between Electricity Curriculum Available and SBAE Teachers’ Perceived Importance to Teach Electricity
PRESENTER: Haley Matney

ABSTRACT. The purpose of this study is to identify if a relationship exists between the electricity curriculum available to teach and perceived importance of teaching key electricity competencies prior to and after attending a workshop.Overall, the findings showed no significant relationship between curriculum and perceived importance prior to the workshop, but consistent positive relationships existed after the workshop. The workshop offered hands-on training that helped teachers recognize the relevance of their curriculum and strengthened alignment between prior training and perceived importance of teaching electricity.

10:45
Haley Matney (Texas State University, United States)
Ryan Anderson (Texas State University, United States)
Knowing By Doing: Does A Relationship Between The Importance To Teach And Ability To Perform Electrical Skills Exist?
PRESENTER: Haley Matney

ABSTRACT. The purpose of this study was to investigate if relationship between the ability to perform electricity skills and SBAE teachers’ perceived importance to teach electricity within the SBAE curriculum exists. We can conclude that the SBAE teachers’ ability to perform electrical skills prior to attending the workshop had no statistical relationship with what the teachers perceived to be important to teach. Identifying that electrical skills were important to teach and lacking the ability to perform said skills was most likely the driving force in participating in the summer workshop. We can conclude that participating in the workshop fostered a statistically significant relationship between the SBAE teachers’ ability to perform electrical skills and what teachers perceived to be important to teach.

11:30-13:00Lunch Break
11:30-13:00 Session 12: Roundtable Presentations #2
Chair:
Larae Watkins (University of Central Missouri, United States)
Anthony Perry (University of North Dakota, United States)
Dynamic Policy Modeling for CTE Policy and Research

ABSTRACT. Career and Technical Education (CTE) exists at the intersection of education and labor market systems, creating policy challenges characterized by complexity, feedback loops, and non-linearities. This work-in-progress demonstrates how system dynamics (SD) modeling can complement traditional social science methods by extending two published CTE studies. The first vignette revisits school-industry partnerships for work-based learning, examining how relational trust and feedback processes influence long-term student opportunities. The second reevaluates persistent gender disparities in STEM-related CTE participation, exploring the effects of federal policy interventions and temporal delays. Using reference modes and causal loop diagrams derived from prior research, preliminary SD models illustrate how feedback structures can reveal mechanisms, generate new theoretical insights, and inform policy design.

Jarvis Gray (North Carolina State University, United States)
Anthony Gray (Dunwoody College of Technology, United States)
Paula Gray (Old Dominion University, United States)
Should Employability Skills Be Considered Safety Skills? A Conceptual Framework Linking Employability Skills and Workplace Safety Functions
PRESENTER: Jarvis Gray

ABSTRACT. Employability skills and workplace safety competencies have developed as largely separate literatures despite substantial behavioral overlap. This conceptual paper uses a theory-synthesis approach (Jaakkola, 2020) to examine how employability skills relate to workplace safety functions. Communication, teamwork, leadership, problem-solving, adaptability, and accountability align closely with the non-technical skills that underpin safe functions. Three points of convergence anchor the synthesis: safety climate and hazard reporting, safety leadership and organizational learning, and safer behaviors developed in CTE settings. A conceptual framework positions employability skills as antecedent competencies shaping workplace safety through safety climate, hazard recognition and reporting, safety learning, and safe work practices. The framework generates testable propositions linking CTE workforce preparation to workplace safety functions.

Mi Hee Park (Auburn University, United States)
Xue Xing (University of Nevada, Las Vegas, United States)
Seong Ji Jeong (Pennsylvania State University, United States)
Capturing Professional Growth in Real Time: A Longitudinal Diary Study of High School Students During IT Internships
PRESENTER: Mi Hee Park

ABSTRACT. Internships are widely recognized as valuable work-based learning experiences, yet most research relies on retrospective interviews or surveys after the experience has ended. Consequently, relatively less is known about how students’ professional learning develops during internships. This qualitative study explores the experiences of marginalized high school students participating in IT internships through solicited weekly diaries. Guided by Career Capital Theory, diaries were analyzed using thematic analysis to examine developmental patterns across the internship. Initial findings suggest that students progressed through four developmental phases: workplace orientation, productive technical struggle, collaborative participation, and emerging professional identity. The study illustrates the value of longitudinal diary methods for capturing workplace learning as it unfolds and offers methodological and practical implications for work-based learning research.

Charlene Smith (University of Maryland Eastern Shore, United States)
Susan Wienand (Lancaster County Career and Technical Education Center, United States)
Employer and Post-Secondary Perceptions of Industry Credentials Earned by High School Students in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania
PRESENTER: Charlene Smith

ABSTRACT. Industry-recognized credentials have become an important part of Career and Technical Education as policymakers seek to strengthen the connection between secondary education and workforce needs. As Perkins V expanded accountability for CTE programs, IRCs helped programs demonstrate technical skill attainment. Research indicates that employers view industry-recognized credentials as valuable indicators of technical competence and workforce preparedness, particularly when they align with industry standards, but gaps remain, and this study addresses those gaps by examining and comparing the perceptions of employers and post-secondary institutions regarding the value, credibility, and usefulness of industry-recognized credentials earned by high school students. The findings will contribute state-specific evidence to support credential selection, improve alignment between education and workforce systems, and inform CTE policy and practice.

13:15-14:15 Session 13A: Research Papers #8
Chair:
Braden Reed (Texas Tech University, United States)
Discussant:
Kevin Elliott (Pittsburg State University, United States)
Location: 314, LBJ Center
13:15
Anthony Gray (Old Dominion University, United States)
Adam Atwell (Old Dominion University, United States)
Concourse-Based Assessment: An Environment-Specific Approach to Career Exploration and Person-Environment Fit
PRESENTER: Anthony Gray

ABSTRACT. Person-environment fit is associated with satisfaction, persistence, retention, and performance across educational and organizational settings. However, many fit assessments rely on standardized researcher-developed items that may not fully reflect the unique characteristics of specific environments. This conceptual paper introduces Concourse-Based Assessment (CBA), an environment-specific approach that derives assessment content directly from environmental discourse. Drawing on person-environment fit theory, concourse theory and Q methodology, realistic job preview research, and organizational socialization literature, CBA proposes a four-stage framework consisting of concourse development, statement construction, participant engagement, and interpretation. The framework is presented as a tool for reflection, expectation alignment, career exploration, advising, and onboarding. Implications, limitations, and directions for future research are discussed.

13:30
Mustapha Kayode Seriki (The Pennsylvania State University, United States)
Shanshan Liu (Universiti of Malaya, China)
Kayode Elijah Adedayo (Kwara State College of Education (Technical) Lafiagi, Nigeria)
Martins Ndashiru (Kwara State College of Education (Technical) Lafiagi, Nigeria)
Mohammed Gana Mohammed (Kwara State College of Education (Technical) Lafiagi, Nigeria)
Ibrahim Anyass Alhassan (The Pennsylvania State University, Ghana)
Umar Adam (The Pennsylvania State University, United States)
Integrating Employability Skills into TVET Through Service Learning: An Experiential Learning Approach

ABSTRACT. The increasing demand for graduates who possess both technical competence and employability skills has intensified concerns among employers and education stakeholders. Many Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) graduates lack essential soft skills required for effective workplace performance, highlighting the need for improved pedagogical approaches. This paper examines service learning as a student-centered experiential teaching strategy for strengthening technical and employability skills among TVET students. Drawing on a library-based research design, the study synthesizes evidence from scholarly sources to evaluate the effectiveness of experiential learning models. The review demonstrates that service learning enhances communication, teamwork, problem-solving, and civic responsibility while reinforcing technical competencies through community engagement. It is recommended that TVET administrators integrate service learning into program curricula.

13:15-14:15 Session 13B: Research Papers #9
Chair:
Gary Lowery (Claremont Graduate University, United States)
Discussant:
John Cannon (University of Idaho, United States)
Location: 315, LBJ Center
13:15
Jenna Schultz (Texas State University, United States)
Ryan Anderson (Texas State University, United States)
Identifying the Amount of Post-Secondary Electrical Training Received by School-Based Agricultural Education Teachers
PRESENTER: Jenna Schultz

ABSTRACT. The results of this study reinforce long-standing concerns in the agricultural education literature regarding insufficient technical preparation among agricultural education teachers. Participants in this study reported low levels of post-secondary coursework in electricity, despite being expected to teach this complex content area in their professional roles. On average, teachers completed only 3.49 post-secondary credit hours in agricultural mechanics, and nearly 60% reported no prior experience teaching electricity. This gap in preparation is critical because electricity instruction requires not only technical skills but also a strong emphasis on safety, making proper training essential for protecting both teachers and students.

13:30
Matthew Bornak (The Pennsylvania State University, United States)
Mark Threeton (Pennsylvania State University, United States)
Joey Fleck (Pennsylvania State University, United States)
Closing the Competency Gap: Aligning Professional Development to Empirically Identified Training Needs in Competency-Based Teacher Education for Career and Technical Education
PRESENTER: Matthew Bornak

ABSTRACT. This study examined discrepancies between in-service CTE teachers' perceived importance of and reported development in leadership competencies. Participants (N = 133) rated 35 competencies on five-point importance and development scales. Using Borich's mean weighted discrepancy scores (MWDS), the largest training gaps emerged in highly valued competencies: self-responsibility, job-specific technical competence, interpersonal competence, occupational technical competence, and computer literacy. These findings reframe professional development planning from broad coverage toward targeted, gap-aligned investment. Interpreted through a Competency-Based Teacher Education framework, the discrepancy hierarchy identifies competencies where teachers feel least prepared despite valuing them highly. Implications support data-informed PD prioritization, mentorship design, and iterative refinement of CBTE models for CTE.

13:45
Jenna Schultz (Texas State University, United States)
Kenedy Kornegay (Texas State University, United States)
Ryan Anderson (Texas State University, United States)
An Evaluation of School-Based Agricultural Education Teachers' Ability to Teach Electricity
PRESENTER: Jenna Schultz

ABSTRACT. This study explored the impact of an electricity workshop on School-Based Agricultural Education (SBAE) teachers’ ability to teach electricity. SBAE teachers possessing the self-efficacy related to the skills they must teach is crucial. SBAE teachers can acquire these skills by attending professional development for topics they have little training in. This study was guided by Kolb’s Experiential Learning Theory. Data were collected using pre and post-paper-based tests on the SBAE teachers’ change in perception of ability to teach four electrical constructs. The results showed that each construct had a positive change

14:15-14:45Coffee Break
14:45-15:45 Session 14: Research Connections

Looking for new collaborators? Feeling inspired to launch new research? Come to this session to make new connections and plot new projects. We will facilitate a a quck process to connect with attendees with similar interests and provide space to discuss new ideas. Leave the conference with concrete next steps for a new project!

Chairs:
Anthony Perry (University of North Dakota, United States)
Charlene Smith (University of Maryland-Eastern Shore, United States)
16:00-17:00 Session 15: ACTER Business Meeting
Chair:
Ryan Anderson (Texas State University, United States)
17:00-19:30 Session 16: ECMCF Postsecondary CTE Research Fellows Focus Groups

Focus groups for past ECMCF Postsecondary CTE Research Fellows

Chairs:
James Bartlett (Old Dominion University, United States)
Michelle Bartlett (Old Dominion University, United States)