WCQR2021: 5TH WORLD CONFERENCE ON QUALITATIVE RESEARCH
PROGRAM FOR THURSDAY, JANUARY 21ST
Days:
previous day
next day
all days

View: session overviewtalk overview

10:30-11:00 Welcome WCQR2021

Fábio Freitas (Politécnico de Leiria and Ludomedia)

Núria Fabrellas (University of Barcelona)

A representative of the Dean of the Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences of the University of Barcelona *

 

* Attendance to be confirmed.

11:00-12:00 Session 6: Plenary Conference

Nurses as a Drive of Change for Better Healthcare

Adelaida Zabalegui (Barcelona University, ES)

Providing high-quality care is a daily challenge for nurses worldwide. This presentation will focus on the proposals and advances of Nursing Now on nursing leadership at all levels, including in management, administration, entrepreneurship and politics. Nursing Now is a world campaign in collaboration with World Health Organization (WHO) and International Council of Nurses (ICN) to foster Nursing development globally. The vision of the campaign is aimed at improving health by rising the profile and status of nurses. It is aimed to assist Governments, politicians, decision makers and managers on the need and benefits of investing in Nursing, so that nurses’ expertise could fully used their competencies, and positively impact individual, social and community health. The campaign is based on the triple impact of nursing identified from APPG (UK Parliament): improvement in health, gender equality and better economy, as well as the need to advance in healthcare universal coverage.To achieve the best care possible and professional effectiveness, nurses must be empowered from leadership. In addition to the knowledge acquired during higher education, specialties, masters and doctorates, nurses must have the possibility of participation in decision-making about health. In addition, this presentation will talk about the Nursing Now recommendations for the redesign of healthcare and thus respond to the growing challenges, to be able to achieve higher objectives even when there are fewer resources and providing solutions to problems for the most needy and vulnerable groups, through the implementation of new models, structures and processes in health care.

12:10-13:50 Session 7A: Rationale and Paradigms of Qualitative Research
Chair:
12:10
Improvement of the (complex) process of creating news of events that have an impact on national security

ABSTRACT. Introduction The news’ creation process is complex because it collaboratively involves different stakeholders (e.g. sources, journalists, editors, sociologists) with seemingly contradictory needs. It is therefore important to better understand what those parties are and their respective needs, particularly in the case of news that may influence National Security.

Goals and Methods 52 students of Communication Sciences’ bachelor degree participated in a Brainstorming on the theme: “How to produce news that do not impact National Security?”, which resulted in a set of words around How is the (current) process, Who are the stakeholders already/to be involved and their motivations, and What alarms / worries people in the news. The data obtained confirmed that there is limited knowledge about the specific process of such news and thus the need to continue research using a qualitative methodology, which included the collection and content analysis of 15 semi-structured individual interviews to reporters, editors, sociologists, psychologists, security forces, and hospital managers. Additionally the Brainstorming results also supported the elaboration of the interview questions while the interviews were literally analyzed with the support of NVivo.

Results Qualitative data analysis allowed the identification of three main codes based on the questions posed “Who is/should be involved, What is important, and How is/should be the language used”, in the perspective of each profession. A relevant contribution found is that journalists have insufficient training in assessing news’ harmful impacts or preparing for disasters.

Conclusions. This research contributes with an innovative exploratory study because previous studies have only addressed specific stakeholder groups. Thus this work initiates a critical reflection on the news’ developing process that may influence National Security so that in the future they can meet the needs of all parties involved and at the same time prevent harmful effects on society, especially in the case of emerging risks.

12:30
Gender Equality: an exploratory qualitative study of social representations on existing practices and dynamics in four municipalities of Baixo Alentejo, Portugal
PRESENTER: Sandra Saúde

ABSTRACT. Portugal has assumed gender equality as one of its six strategic priorities in the process of implementing the 2030 Agenda – Sustainable Development Goals. Although promotion of strategies and actions has increased and diver-sified over the past years, the latest official reports reveal that equality be-tween men and women in several fields does not go beyond a formal status. The qualitative case study developed explores and characterizes the social representations of local key , political and intervention, actors on the mean-ing, domains and practices and dynamics to promote gender equality in four municipalities of NUTS III – Baixo Alentejo, taking five local action frame-work documents and nine in-depth interviews as sources. With the combined use of T-Lab and webQDA software tools (Computer-Assisted Qualitative Data Analysis Software), a thematic content analysis was carried out on the corpus formed by: 1) the textual sections related to gender equality contained in the documents and 2) the transcriptions of re-sponses. The most repeated keywords were identified with T-Lab and a "word association" analysis was performed. With webQDA, the thematic content analysis was organized by categories and subcategories which al-lowed the structuring elements of the social representations on gender equal-ity contained that emerged from the analysed corpus to be identified and in-terpreted. The analysis carried out clearly reveals an incomplete approach to gender equality in terms of local dynamics and practices, as the intervention is mainly focused on a single aspect, such as domestic violence. Despite the ex-isting normative framework and policy guidelines, the study carried out re-veals that most key actors lack knowledge regarding some gender equality problems and domains and fail to identify evidences of inequality, which negatively influences the implemented action plans.

12:50
Perceptions of professionals about gender violence from a ludic and educational game
PRESENTER: Lucimara Fornari

ABSTRACT. Introduction: Violetas is a cooperative and strategic game, which aims to subsidize learning about gender violence. It also allows for the exchange of experiences among public policymakers and other professionals dealing with gender violence. Objectives: To identify and analyse the perceptions of professionals about violence against women, under gender category. Methods: This is a qualitative study, part of a larger project entitled “Potentials and limits of the game Violetas for confronting gender violence”. The participants were professionals responsible who assist women in situations of violence at the institution called Casa da Mulher Brasileira (CMB). Data were collected in the three CMB: Brasília, Campo Grande and Curitiba. Filled forms, digital images and sound recordings were used in the mixed data collection modality: critical-emancipatory workshop and participant observation. After the transcriptions, the data treatment was performed according to the thematic content analysis technique with the support of webQDA software. Results: In total, thirty professionals from different sectors of the institutions participated in the research. An empirical category emerged: Perceptions of professionals in relation to violence against women. In this category, participants considered that violence against women is based on gender stereotypes reinforced by biological differences. They recognized female subordination in public life through salary and job differences, and in private life through responsibility for domestic activities and care of children. The discourses also addressed issues related to the objectification of the female body and sexual and reproductive rights. According to the participants, violence against women causes feelings of blame, helplessness, isolation, confinement and pain. They believe that women's empowerment is a possibility to confront the problem. Conclusions: The game provided reflections on the different expressions of gender violence in the public and private life of the women. Hence, this is an important technology in training and qualifying professionals about the thematic.

13:10
Action-Research Methodology: an integrative literature review, through webQDA.
PRESENTER: Davys Moreno

ABSTRACT. In 2018, an Action Research project was initiated with the aim of contributing to the Inclusive Education of Children with Special Needs in the Arts Education Programmes in Portugal. The study was initiated by the enrolment of a child with Cerebral Palsy in the Music Arts Education Programmes. The objective of this work was to define the methodology to be used – action-research - in order to justify the methodological choice of this research project in relation to other options. Therefore, we conducted an integrative literature review on the action-research methodology. We started by selecting reference authors in action-research methodology. Then we looked for studies carried out with this methodology, related to the theme of our research project. For this purpose, we used different databases (b-on, Elsevier, ERIC, Google Scholar, Scielo, Scopus and Web of Science), through keywords related to the theme under study: action-research, inclusion, music education, music learning, special education, cerebral palsy, physical disability, special needs, assistive technology, assistive devices, and music arts education programmes. All the compiled information was organized and studied through content analysis supported by the software package webQDA, which proved to be effective for the characterization of the information. We observed that there are not many rigorous studies in our area using this methodology. Despite this, in view of other methodological possibilities, we confirm this methodology as being the most appropriate for our type of study, allowing us to perform an in-depth comprehension of the problems and practical situations, involving the subjects participating in the construction of knowledge. Finally, the integrative literature review using webQDA as a content analysis tool helped us to gain a deeper understanding of the methodological process, making us more aware of its potentialities and limitations.

12:10-13:50 Session 7B: Systematization of approaches with Qualitative Studies
12:10
Nursing Interventions to Multimorbidity Oncologic Patients: Scoping Review
PRESENTER: Cristina Moreira

ABSTRACT. Introduction Multimorbidity (MM) is a rising phenomenon, described as the presence of two or more chronic illnesses, that has in itself a poor prognosis and worse quality of life, increasing health expense, and inappropriate use of available resources. Nurses have a paramount role, in order to intervenne to promote comfort. Goals and methods With the goal of mapping nursing interventions directed to the oncologic patient with MM, arises this scoping review. The starting question was “Which nursing interventions improve the quality of care provided to multimorbidity oncological patients?” A PCC framework was designed, following the Joanna Briggs Institute (2017) methodology. CINAHL and MEDLINE data bases were research, and eight articles were retrieved, after applying inclusion criteria. Data extraction was undertaken by two independent revisers. Results In all articles there is a scarcity of structured nursing interventions. Some studies suggest that these interventions should be grouped by domains: physical, environmental, social and psycho-emotional. Being a global approach, it is difficult to separate nursing interventions; therefore, some studies group them in structured programs. It is argued that changes at all levels should happen: either organizational, and in management policies allowing service reorganization as well as the health professionals themselves, regarding the patient as a whole, inserted in a multidisciplinary team. Finally, it is also highlighted the need to intervene on the social and family environment, with coordination of available community care, allowing patients to remain active, avoiding isolation. Conclusions It was concluded that organizational changes are imperative, as well as, from health care professionals, through a concerted intervention, focused on structured programs. These programs should center on all domains. Finally, it was noted a lack of evidence concerning the efficacy of the nurse interventions identified, requiring further investigation.

12:30
"Becoming a Mother of a Second Child: The moment of returning home and everyday life"

ABSTRACT. Introduction

Becoming the mother of a second child, as a specific phenomenon of transition in parenting, represents a period of greater (trans)formation and vulnerability of the person, as a “being-in-the-world”, in the encounter of his new identity, that leads to needs in the health domain.

However, this transition is poorly investigated. Having access to the meaning attributed to the lived experience of the woman who becomes the mother of a second child opens a new perspective of understanding on this phenomenon of transition from parenting.

Goals

This study aimed to understand the meaning of the lived experience of the woman who becomes the mother of a second child. The investigation is part of a qualitative methodology, with a hermeneutical phenomenological design.

Methods   

The experiential material was collected from phenomenological interviews with 11 women, with a second child aged between 18 and 24 months. The activities developed in the data analysis process took van Manen's guidelines into account.

Findings

The moment of returning home and everyday life: everything is a lotI need more ... was one of the identified themes that commonly emerged from the participants' narratives where the following variations are included: I want to be here, but I also want to be there…: I wasn't being a everything-right mother…Time for us is zero: giving everything from ourselves; The experience of the essential: oh mom, I'm here!I need more: a lot but with the support of one other….

Conclusions

Through this study, nurses can access the lived experience of these women and with these findings improve their intervention.

12:50
Transcribe or not transcribe ?

ABSTRACT. Choosing a qualitative method for research often means carrying out interviews, which are then accompanied by the corpus transcription. However, the transcription process and its usefulness are generally little discussed from a methodological point of view in the communication of research results. When considering the activity of transcription within a broader process of research work, two main uses can be identified. Transcription facilitates the work of analysis on the basis of a written corpus and then the presentation of the results in written form. However, the work of transcription, except a huge spend of time, requires specific skills related to linguistics. In this field, it is not uncommon to consider transcription as a first discourse interpretation. It is therefore understandable that this stage prior to data analysis is a delicate one. Yet students rarely receive adequate training or pedagogical support for this task. This paper proposes to question the validity of the full transcription of corpora in training programs at master's level, by establishing the state-of-the art on transcription, and then by questioning the practices and beliefs of teachers in charge of directing master's theses in a swiss university, involving transcription during qualitative approaches. The initial results show that, generally speaking, teachers do not question the merits of the approach or its validity. They recognize the lack of training and methods offered to students as well as the difficulty experienced by students in this task. However, they do not consider any other way of proceeding. The continuation of this work will make it possible to reflect on the adjustments to be proposed in the training of master's level students in order to make students work directly on the audio corpus, without going through the complete transcription into recordings, while maintaining (and improving) the quality of data processing.

13:10
Fall risk management in nursing homes: results of action research

ABSTRACT. Introduction: The evidence about risk factors and preventive measures to control risk, falls, secondary injuries and their severity have been productive, but have not been translated into the clinic. The prevalence of falls in nursing homes remains high and with serious consequences on the loss of functionality and quality of life in institutionalized elderly. Goals: Identify fall risk management practices in nursing home; Design, implement and evaluate a fall risk management program in nursing homes. Methods: Action research study. Participants were professionals and elderly from a Portuguese nursing home. For this communication we present the data from the first phase: diagnosis of the problem, that allows identifying the model in use. Data collection was carried out through participant observation, interview and application of scales. Results: The teams do not systematically identify the risk of falling and decide, individually and occasionally, the preventive measures. There is a concern with the control of environmental risk and difficulties in preventive practices during the supervision of the elderly's daily activities. The team discusses the occurrence of falls, blaming themselves for them, but is not in the habit of sharing information about risk and preventive measures. The health team guides the introduction of some measures, but the process of delegating tasks is not clear in order to ensure safety. After a fall episode, professionals expect a decline in the elderly's functionality but do not monitor it. The fall phenomenon causes fear in professionals and the elderly, the former opt for a paternalistic attitude of overprotection and the latter decrease activity - both processes push the elderly to a high degree of fragility and dependence. Conclusion: Clarifying the model in use to manage the risk and fall increases the understanding of the problem and guides the interventions to be included in fall risk management program.

13:30
Corporate Social Responsibility and Good Governance Practices in State-Owned Enterprises in Portugal

ABSTRACT. This research aims to explore the concept and the different perspectives of corporate social responsibility and good governance practices in state-owned enterprises in Portugal, given its relevance in national economic activity. A diagnosis of these companies’ practices and disclosure policies was carried out, with regard to environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues. The methodology focuses on the combination of content analysis matrices in order to validate the quality of non-financial disclosure regarding ESG practices and to set the companies' transparency index. This approach may be used by other similar studies, regardless of the type of entity, in the public or private sector. This evaluation model, based on content analysis of the different types of information disclosed on the companies' web pages, assumes two distinct stages. In the first stage, assigning score methods were developed to estimate the degree of compliance of companies in matters of disclosure, as well as the level of transparency. The second stage, based on the construction of indexes by group, will allow evaluating the quality of the information disclosed. It was concluded that a significant part of companies does not disclose all the information legally required on their websites, access is not always direct and, often, information is out of date. Although larger companies are quite transparent in the dissemination of information and have assumed a greater number of environmental and social commitments, some of the public sector companies are not yet contributing to the good implementation of public policies or to the dissemination of good practices in the economic, social and environmental fields. Summing up, it was not possible to consider state-owned companies in Portugal as the best example in good governance practices and disclosure policies of ESG issues.

14:00-15:30 Session 8A: Workshop

NCRM Workshop: Changing Research Practices for Covid-19

Melanie Nind (National Centre for Research Methods/ Education School, University of Southampton, UK), Robert Meckin (National Centre for Research Methods/ School of Social Sciences, University of Manchester, UK) and Andy Coverdale (National Centre for Research Methods/ Education School, University of Southampton, UK)

The context for this workshop is the Covid-19 global pandemic and its impact on qualitative research. Globally, qualitative social researchers are having to re-think or plan their research to take into account the public health mandates including local/national lockdowns, travel and access restrictions, and necessity to wear face coverings and keep distance from others. In the UK, the National Centre for Research Methods has been funded to explore ‘Changing Research Practices for Undertaking Social Science Research in the Context of Covid-19’.

This workshop aims to engage participants who are working on their methodological responses to researching during the pandemic. The workshop design draws on a workshop series the facilitators ran in the UK. Participants will discursively reflect on the core challenges in conducting field work, including shifts to online and other creative spaces, and the associated ethical and validity issues. A strategy of exploring recent research history with the visual metaphor of a river will assist participants to look afresh – at the rapids, meanders, whirlpools etc - of researching in Covid times. The expected outcome is renewed energy for keeping qualitative fieldwork going with (at least of the) problems shared and solved. The workshop will last for two hours.

14:00-15:30 Session 8B: Workshop

Critical Self-Reflection in Qualitative Research

Anna CohenMiller (Graduate School of Education Nazarbayev University, Nur-Sultan, Kazakhstan), Nettie Boivin (Department of Applied Linguistics University of Jväskaylä, Yväskaylä Finland)

Have you ever wondered if you were doing enough in your research? Perhaps you’ve wondered if you’ve spoken to enough people, heard their views deeply enough, or explained their lived experiences enough? Perhaps you’ve wondered how you can show or evidence your rigor to create socially-just research? In working with graduate students from around the world, these same questions often bubble up. Many have wanted to know the recipe or the formula for doing good, ethical, and socially responsible qualitative research. While there is no silver-bullet answer providing the answer to these questions, this workshop offers something more insightful—a chance to negotiate self-reflection to enhance your understanding and practice.

In this workshop, we will come together collectively to create a safe, community space to learn about critical self-reflection in qualitative inquiry. You will be guided through opportunities to explore ideas and perceptions about research with a supportive group of peers and step away with practical tools to deepen your understanding and practice of qualitative research.

14:00-15:30 Session 8C: Workshop

Qualitative Research while working from home using webQDA

Michael White (Research Office, Universidad Peruana Unión, Peru)

Research doesn’t stop just because we can’t go to our offices or out in the field. Social media and virtual conference rooms allow for a wide range of qualitative research studies, even while working from home. This workshop will show you some practical examples of how you can use webQDA to organize and analyze qualitative data from places you might not expect in order to inspire you to create your own qualitative research project. Facebook, Google Forms, Zoom, WhatsApp, and even YouTube can be used with webQDA. Want to know how? Come see how easy it is in this hands-on, informative workshop. All you need is a free 15-day trial of webQDA to get started!

14:00-15:30 Session 8D: Workshop

Making the most of rich data

Fiona Wiltshier (Timberlake Consultants, UK)

One of the most powerful aspects of working qualitatively is that you can use a wide variety of different types of data, offering the opportunity to explore topics in even more depth. Traditionally, as qualitative researchers, we have worked with text data, and while this is still of course a core element of qualitative data, there are now so many more options to consider.This workshop will show you how you can use NVivo to work with many different types of data, going beyond text to look at how you can work with audio and video recordings, images, surveys and social media as well as including text as needed.

We will look at bringing different data sources into a project; organising, coding and analysing them; then moving on to look at ways of exploring and visualising data in a variety of ways.

 

15:40-17:10 Session 9A: Panel Discussion: Data Collection Methods Through Online Modalities

Data Collection Methods Through Online Modalities

 David Lumowa (Adventist International Institute of Advanced Studies, Silang, Cavite, Philippines), Arceli Rosario (Adventist International Institute of Advanced Studies, Silang, Cavite, Philippines), Pavel Zubkov (Adventist International Institute of Advanced Studies, Silang, Cavite, Philippines) and Safary Wa-Mbaleka  (Adventist University of Africa, Nairobi, Kenya)

AbstractThe COVID-19 pandemic has not only affected the world’s economy, the delivery of education and other services, but also how research is conducted. Travel bans and policies on social and physical distancing have restricted researchers’ mobility to reach and be at natural settings and made it impossible for them to have face-to-face interactions with their participants on the site. So the question is, Shall researchers stop conducting research studies because of the challenging times? We would say, No. On the contrary, at these times, research is significantly important, more than ever. We grapple with a phenomenon that is complex and that impacts our lives very deeply. We have many questions to answer, and one of the best tools available to us is the qualitative research approach. Hence, in this panel discussion, our team would like to engage qualitative researchers in a conversation regarding the use of internet technologies for conducting online research, specifically data collection methods such as in-depth interviews, observation, focus group discussions, and other alternatives can be done through online modalities.

15:40-17:10 Session 9B: Panel Discussion "From qualitative methodology to mixed methods in systematic observation of physical activity and sport: An approach to quantitizing"

From qualitative methodology to mixed methods in systematic observation of physical activity and sport: An approach to quantitizing

Teresa Anguera (Faculty of Psychology, Institute of Neurosciences, University of Barcelona, Barcelona, España), Oleguer Camerino (National Institute of Physical Education of Catalonia -INEFC, Institute of Biomedical Research Foundation Dr. Pifarré -IRB Lleida, University of Lleida, Lleida, España), Marta Castañer (National Institute of Physical Education of Catalonia -INEFC, Institute of Biomedical Research Foundation Dr. Pifarré -IRB Lleida, University of Lleida, Lleida, España) and Mariona Portell (Department of Psychobiology and Health Sciences Methodology, Autonomous University of Barcelona, Cerdanyola del Vallés, España)

In recent years there have been various clashes between supporters of the misnamed qualitative and quantitative methodologies (and we say ‘misnamed’ because the coverage of both is so wide that hardly conform to a methodology in the strict sense). The field of physical activity and sport has not been left behind, and the literature shows us this radicalism. For several decades, systematic observation in physical activity and sport was characterized by qualitative-quantitative radicalism. Our research group works in both dimensions, but in this discussion panel, specifically, we are interested in the qualitative aspect. In our work we have developed: life stories, event descriptions, transcripts of radio broadcasts in sports competitions, interviews with physical educators, comments on discussions in the dressing rooms, etc., which had in common the textual style in which the study began and ended, and that they adjusted to the standards of qualitative research. In Anguera, Camerino, Castañer, Sánchez-Algarra and  Onwuebuzie (2017) it is documented that in the last quarter of the century interest has increased in the use of qualitative methodology in physical activity and sports studies, which can be attributed to a combination of theoretical and pragmatic elements (Moran, James, & Kirby, 2011). In the study by Culver, Gilbert and Trundel (2003), the qualitative papers published in this area only reached 17%. But researchers of physical activity and sport, although without ceasing to criticize the qualitative methodology (Sparkes, 1998), have been progressively attracted by the possibility of delving into the personal perspectives and experiences of the participants of physical activity training and competitions and sport, which involves a wide range of possibilities, and the emergence of the narrative inquiry in physical activity and sport has contributed to this (Monforte, Pérez-Samaniego, & Devís-Devís, 2018; Smith & Sparkes, 2009).

17:20-19:00 Session 10A: Qualitative and Mixed Methods Research
17:20
Assessing teachers and peer teacher students’ perceptions of their motivations and participation impact in peer learning projects: the role of content analysis supported by WebQDA

ABSTRACT. Introduction: According to literature review, the number of studies focusing on Computer-Assisted Qualitative-Data Analysis Software (CAQDAS) as well as on clear descriptions of how these tools can be used is still scarce. Besides this, despite the recognition of content analysis for its appropriateness to qualitative studies, several authors refer to ambiguity problems, mostly related to the subjectivity of the coding process, which may interfere with the assurance of the validity criteria of stability, reproducibility and accuracy. Goals and methods: This study is predominately methodological and focuses on a segment of the results of a multiple case study, involving five peer learning projects, implemented in five Portuguese educational institutions; and on the re-flection on the role of content analysis, as the chosen data analysis technique, and the support of qualitative analysis software WebQDA, particularly regarding the assurance of the validity criteria of reproducibility and accuracy. By means of a semi-structured interview and a survey by questionnaire, this study aims at assessing teachers and peer teacher students’ perceptions of motivations to integrate the projects as well as of the contributions resulting from participation, regarding benefits and major challenges; and analyse the role of content analysis, supported by software WebQDA, in identifying these teachers and peer teacher students’ convergent/divergent perceptions. Results: Results show there is clear convergence of teachers and peer teacher students’ perceptions regarding the three variables assessed, particularly as for participation benefits. It is also evident that teachers and peer teacher students’ perceptions diverge in matters related to specificities of the role assumed in the projects. The contribution of software WebQDA was particularly significant re-garding the transparency, structure and systematization facilitated. Conclusions: Conclusions enhance the role of content analysis and of software WebQDA for promoting reflexive and in-depth analysis of the collected data and for assuring replication of the study.

17:40
Construction and Validation of a Rapport Observation System
PRESENTER: Carla Martins

ABSTRACT. Introduction: Martins is developing a holistic intervention model in sport that makes an interface between sport psychology, neurolinguistic programming and neurolinguistic coaching. The main tool used to guide sport actors is observation, so it is important to have a trustworthy instrument. The main goal is to build and validate a Rapport Observation System (Sistema de Observação de Rapport – SOR) between the coach and the coachee. The sample are the observation periods considered to validate the instrument. As a method it will be used Systematic Observation, involving four tasks: i) construction of the categories; ii) construction of the observation manual; iii) construction of the registration instrument; iv) validity and reliability by consensus, Cohen's Kappa, through intra and inter-subject observations. Result: SOR consists of 4 levels of categories: 4th - rapport; 3rd - coach and coachee behaviors; 2nd - for the coach we have 5 subcategories: proximity behavior; mirroring; voice characteristics; active listening; other behaviors; 2nd - for the coachee we have 6 subcategories of which the only one that is different from the coach categories, is make confidences; 1st - regarding the coach, a total of 42 behaviors were observed and concerning the coachee, a total of 36 behaviors were identified. SOR consists of a total of 78 behaviors that define rapport. Conclusions: as the focus of this abstract is to build and validate a Rapport Observation System (SOR), the inductive recategorization process is ongoing at this stage, having already obtained the opinion of the panels of NLP specialists, of psychologists and of the specialists in sport and exercise. As a result, we have already obtained a System of Categories that is being used for intra and inter-observer validation that is taking place. In a first analysis, there is evidence of the need to validate the SOR using more coaches.

18:00
Identifying challenges and proposing solutions for disease models with the Congenital Disorders of Glycosylation Community: A mixed research approach
PRESENTER: Rita Francisco

ABSTRACT. Introduction: Congenital Disorders of Glycosylation (CDG) are a fast-expanding family of rare and medically complex diseases mostly lacking effective treatments[1]. Disease models are essential tools in the drug development process [2] and several have been developed for CDGs. However, a well-accepted CDG disease model is missing.

Aim: To understand the CDG disease models landscape and signal future directions by identifying challenges and solutions in a community needs-assessment exercise. For that, we aimed to join the vision of CDG families and professionals with the prospect of accelerating disease models generation for effective therapy-development.  

Methods: A mixed-research approach was framed within the 4th World Conference on CDG for Families and Professionals. A quantitative electronic survey was developed using SurveyMonkey platform, distributed through social media and analysed via descriptive statistics tools. Qualitative analysis of the transcriptions of Think Tank discussions recorded during the conference was performed by two independent researchers using Nvivo coding.

Results: CDG family members (n=82) and professionals (n=46) answered the survey. Most participants believed that CDG disease models were essential for CDG therapy-driven research and 46% of professionals reported to use disease models in their research. High costs and lack of investment were identified as the major obstacles for disease models development by the CDG community both in the survey and during Think Thank discussions. The lack of existing suitable models and the issues related to model translatability to humans were also extensively raised in the Think Tanks. Participants recognised the need to conduct more research on this topic and the investment in simpler models to reduce research costs. To address translatability issues investment in more complex animal models was suggested.

Conclusion: This innovative, community-framed research approach has shed light on the status of CDG disease models and suggested future directions to this prime topic for therapy research and development. 

18:20
Dealing with the power asymmetry in expert interview

ABSTRACT. This presentation will introduce the author’s experience of conducting face-to-face interviews with experts. The research employed grounded theory as a framework to collect and analyze qualitative data. It is a part of a PhD research on the impact of state-sponsored religious schools on youth’s religiosity in Turkey. After briefly introducing the existing literature on religious schools in Turkey and expert interview, this paper reflects upon the interaction of the author as a researcher with the experts. The experts are the civil servants, academics, and teachers and principals of religious schools (Imam Hatip Schools-IHLs) in Turkey. The status of the IHLs is a long-term controversial issue and affected by the ideological stances of every government. Considering the current political environment in Turkey, this research is not a study that experts will easily join it. Thus, the main focus of the presentation will be interviewing experts as a relatively novice researcher in a politically sensitive topic and impact of the power imbalance between the researcher and the researched on the topic under question. It will be elaborated through the discussion of the effect of the researcher’s personal history on the interviewing process, problems in reaching the experts, establishing the rapport, asking questions about a hot topic and receiving answers, and dealing with the cultural roles that affect the interviewing process. All of them, this paper concludes, affect the information gained from the interviews. The knowledge produced through the interaction between the researcher and the researched cannot be considered as totally objective. Rather, it is produced by the actors with different worldviews and influenced by the politics of time.

18:40
Health Information. Traditional Method or Digital Technology?
PRESENTER: Cristina Saraiva

ABSTRACT. Information and the way it’s accessed an essential tool in healthcare and one of the pillars of health literacy. The use of digital technologies is now a social reality. The prevalence of low levels of health literacy in people with COPD limits access, search for health information, online, credible and of quality. Objective: To analyse how the health literacy levels of people with COPD influence access to digital information. Method: Observational, cross-sectional study with a quantitative and qualitative approach. It consists of the evaluation of health literacy, the search for health information and a semi-structured interview to identify the information strategies that contribute to the understanding of the health condition. Results: Participants with a marginal and adequate level of literacy, more often, manifest access to digital technologies to clarify themselves. Furthermore, the use of these is less valued regardless of the level of health literacy. Conclusion: The use of the internet in the search for information depends on individual capacities, sociodemographic factors, health and cognitive conditions and the difficulty in using digital technology and not on the level of health literacy.

17:20-19:20 Session 10B: Rationale and Paradigms of Qualitative Research
17:20
A child with Cerebral Palsy in Arts Education Programs: Building Scaffoldings for Inclusion
PRESENTER: Davys Moreno

ABSTRACT. In order to contribute to the Inclusive Education of Children with Special Needs in the Arts Education Programmes of Music in Portugal, an Action-Research project was started in 2018. With this work we intend to characterize the child that originated the study and to relate their characterization with studies obtained in the literature review, whose theme is the inclusion of children with Special Needs in music teaching. For that, we started with a literature review. The studies considered in the teaching of music highlighted the lack of training of teachers as the greatest barrier to an effective inclusion. Some studies point out some facilitating responses like the use of assistive technology, software and musical technologies. We also sought authors to help us reflect on the learning processes of the child, their development (psychological functions and maturation of the child), the specific relationship between adult and child (scaffolding) and social interactions in the context in which they live. The analysis of "Vygotsky's Cognitive Development Theory" and "Urie Bronfenbrenner's Ecological Theory of Human Development" presented us with this possibility. Besides the literature review, nine interviews were carried out, considering the person in charge of education and the different education and health professionals who work with the child. All information compiled was organised and studied through content analysis supported by Computer-assisted Qualitative Data Analysis Software on the webQDA platform. The results highlight the importance of using assistive technology, music software, adapted musical instruments, etc., to be used in the learning of music, as we found in the literature. They also point out the need for individualised support (people), the need to promote the skills of the professionals working with the child, the accessibility of spaces and the adaptations of programmes. We propose the development of training courses to promote Inclusion.

17:40
The critical incident technique (CIT): a qualitative research tool used in teaching and training

ABSTRACT. The critical incident technique (CIT) makes possible the identification of behaviors that have been observed to lead to success or failure of a specific task. The CIT obtains a record of these specific behaviors from those in the best position to make the necessary observations and evaluations. Inductive in nature, the CIT is recognized today as an effective exploratory and investigative tool. It has been frequently used as a qualitative research method, but was primarily used as a personnel training tool and can be utilized in teaching (e.g., teaching negotiation).

The relational nature of negotiation leads to the huge challenge of transforming students’ interpersonal behaviors. However, merely providing students with opportunities to experiment via role-playing situations is unlikely to be truly transformative. The CIT was chosen as a pedagogical technique because of its analytical and reflexive perspective. The goal was to increase the transformative capacity of role-playing. The learning objectives of the online negotiation course were actually to enhance behaviors relevant to effective sales negotiation. In this presentation, the author describes how he used the CIT in conjunction with role-playing situations with 24 graduate students in marketing and international sales.

The critical incident approach engages participants in examining behaviors critical to their effectiveness. Students had to use an observation form to identify the critical behaviors that can determine the outcome of a sales negotiation. The completed forms made it possible to measure if the learning objectives were met. The CIT utilizes concrete experience and reflective observation learning styles. This presentation will provide with insights about how a qualitative research method may be used in teaching or in personnel training.

18:00
Listening between the lines: how a theoretical framework prevents superficial analysis in qualitative research

ABSTRACT. Introduction: Qualitative researchers strive hard to be taken serious within the field of clinical psychology. Therefore, they typically want to avoid to be accused of being biased. This results in a big focus on bracketing theoretical background and personal assumptions as much as possible. However, this fear of being theoretically biased often leads, in our opinion, to rather superficial analyses. Goal: We will argue how making use of a theoretical framework improves rather than limits the quality of qualitative research. We will use our own research regarding the experience of negative symptoms in psychosis as an example. Methods: We conducted semi-structured interviews with 12 psychotic patients about their experiences of negative symptoms. Interviews were analyzed by means of Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis. The research team has a theoretical background in psychoanalysis and phenomenology and extensive knowledge regarding common theories on negative symptoms. Despite noticing links with theory, our analysis of individual cases remained as close to the words of the participants as possible. Our synthesis of the different cases started atheoretical, but we soon moved to a more theoretical inspired approach as this did more right to the data. Results: Participants preferred to talk about supposed causes of negative symptoms (i.e. secondary negative symptoms), while avoiding to talk about the actual experiences. Based on our theoretical framework we could make sense of this, hypothesizing that negative symptoms are characterized by the impossibility of language to grasp these experiences. The failure of the narrative thus became the central theme in our analyses. Conclusion: An atheoretical analysis would have led to the classical primary versus secondary negative symptoms division and would as such have been of little added value. Our theoretical approach, however, created a deeper insight in the experience of negative symptoms, by providing a lens through which to approach the data.

18:20
Going beyond a conflict of approaches in psychiatric care : the perks of interdisciplinary research
PRESENTER: Heloise Haliday

ABSTRACT. Psychiatric care in France seems to be torn between two conflicting approaches defended by professionals themselves : the first one, based on psychodynamic theories, pleads for a “relational” (Sassolas, 2019) or “artisanal” (Venet, 2020) psychiatric practice, refusing standardized protocols and evaluation on the basis that they erase professionals’ subjectivity at work. The second one, which relies on neurosciences and an evidence-based approach (Leboyer & Llorca, 2018), argues professionals only progress and achieve best practices through the standardization of their therapeutic interactions with patients, either using scales or e-mental health tools. To investigate the reality of day-to-day professional/patient interactions in French psychiatric services, we conducted a qualitative study based on interdisciplinary data gathering and analysis in five psychiatric sectors. The two researchers involved, a sociologist and a clinical psychologist, shared a single ethnographic methodology (Beaud & Weber, 2017) consisting in field observations, note-taking and semi-directed interviews with mental healthcare workers (psychologists, psychiatrists, nurses, nursing assistants…). We will explain how we combined a descriptive paradigm grounded in Ughetto’s sociology of activity (2011) and Bourdieu’s theory of practice (Bourdieu, 2015) on one side, and psychodynamic psychology’s clinical interpretations on the other side, to answer our research question. We will in particular focus on the way this combination, which implied a certain “trouble of having a psychologist sharing field work” (Dasen, 2019) enabled us to draw a typology of “therapeutic styles” beyond the apparent dichotomy between psychodynamic and scientific approaches, as well as offer a clinical interpretation of this currently undergoing conflict in psychiatric care. We will finally propose that a certain degree of formalization, understood as a way for pluriprofessional teams to stay creative in their interactions with patients while building shared mental models (Mathieu, Heffner, Goodwin, Salas, & Cannon-Bowers, 2000) of care, could be a fruitful alternative between improvisation and standardization.

18:40
From research to practice: qualitative methods for complex thinking in ‘real-world’ interventions

ABSTRACT. Many qualitative approaches and methods have been developed as alternatives to the positivistic, reductionist modes of research. They were developed to capture and understand the complexity of the world, while embedding the research process in modes of activity congruent with and capable of performing such complexity. In this paper, we propose that many practices habitual to qualitative researchers can be transferred, adapted and integrated into the development of new tools, strategies and resources specifically aimed at supporting and promoting the practice of complex thinking, for the management of change, towards positive and sustainable outcomes, in the context of ‘real-world’ interventions (e.g. policy-making; program development and evaluation; clinical interventions). Qualitative methods are not new to the toolkits of many program developers and evaluators of real world interventions, namely those informed by more systems oriented and complexity informed modes of thinking. Following the work of Edgar Morin and building on contributions from systems and complexity science, a recent framework proposes the operationalisation of complex thinking through the practice of a coupling relationship with the world that not only attends to but also enacts particular properties of the complex world. An increased coherence and complexity in this coupling is said to lead to more positive actions even in the face of uncertainty and partial information. Strategies familiar to qualitative researchers (‘qualitative thinking’) could be more fully integrated into our natural modes of thinking and contribute to the development of operational tools for the practice of complex thinking. We will explore contributions from particular practices attending to: the complexity of the observer (e.g. reflexivity, multipositioning); structural complexity of the thinking (e.g. variety/multidimensionality; relationality; recursiveness); causal complexity (e.g.emergence; historicity; circularity/parts-whole relations); dynamic complexity (e.g. process and dynamics; ambiguity and uncertainty); ethics, aesthetics; and narrative complexity (e.g. differentiation and integration; identity; flexibility and openness).

19:00
Concepts of Health, Integrality, and Care in Primary Health Care: local managers’ perceptions

ABSTRACT. Health promotion, especially in Primary Care, has been emphasized to integrate health care since the publication of the National Policy of Integrative and Complementary Practices in the Unified Health System (SUS) in 2006, which included 29 complementary therapies. Although Brazil has made significant advances in adhering to this policy to align with international trends, some challenges regarding its effective implementation have been observed. Among the challenges are the stumbling blocks in the conceptual and practical bases guiding the work of the local Primary Health Care (PHC) service managers to construct community health integrality. Therefore, this study aimed to analyze the perceptions of health, integrality, and care of local managers who do not provide or no longer provide complementary therapies in PHC services. This exploratory study with qualitative data analysis was carried out in the Metropolitan Region of Goiânia, Goiás State, Brazil, through semi-structured interviews with 24 local PHC network managers. Data were collected from November to December 2018. The content was analyzed through the thematic analysis technique, with support from NVivo © software. The results show that managers’ health concepts and perceptions are directed towards the well-being and quality of life. Integrality and care are directly related to care provision, and managers put them into practice daily during the work process. It appears that the perceptions are still rooted in the reproduction of actions and practices centered on the biomedical model, which seems to hinder the effective entry of new care models, such as complementary therapies.